On home, oppression, and writing
I’m now in
Jerusalem. Thanks to PARC (Palestine American Research center) and NEH
(National Endowment for Humanities), I have six months to do research and work on writing my book.
It is said that cultivating writing habits makes writing easier, so I'm also trying to start this!
It is said that cultivating writing habits makes writing easier, so I'm also trying to start this!
In some ways, I'm home now.
I was born and raised in a small village in the Galilee, about 100 miles north of Jerusalem. I moved to Jerusalem when I was 18 to attend Law School at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, and lived here until 2004. I loved Jerusalem. I grew up with a romantic image of the city. My parents attended the same university about 30 years before. They met, studied, were political activists, and fell in love here. I loved Jerusalem because of the place that it held in their heart, and I loved it when I came here. And the city never quite gave you a good reason to love it. You could easily romanticize it, the history, the incredible sense of place, the old buildings and narrow roads in the market in the old city, with the magnificent walls surrounding it. But it is also the city that screams racisms and conservatism. You saw segregation everywhere. From the walls of the ivory towers at Hebrew U (overlooking and increasingly dispossessing Issawiyya, the Palestinian adjacent village), to the drive down "Route 1" (which separates East/Arab and West Jerusalem, and which, in part, was the armistice line between 1948-1967), to the stark differences in infrastructure and services between Arab and Jewish Areas. The more you learned, the more you knew how much life in this city was guided by the logic of occupation and discrimination (you can read more about the situation in Jerusalem here).
I was born and raised in a small village in the Galilee, about 100 miles north of Jerusalem. I moved to Jerusalem when I was 18 to attend Law School at the Hebrew University in Jerusalem, and lived here until 2004. I loved Jerusalem. I grew up with a romantic image of the city. My parents attended the same university about 30 years before. They met, studied, were political activists, and fell in love here. I loved Jerusalem because of the place that it held in their heart, and I loved it when I came here. And the city never quite gave you a good reason to love it. You could easily romanticize it, the history, the incredible sense of place, the old buildings and narrow roads in the market in the old city, with the magnificent walls surrounding it. But it is also the city that screams racisms and conservatism. You saw segregation everywhere. From the walls of the ivory towers at Hebrew U (overlooking and increasingly dispossessing Issawiyya, the Palestinian adjacent village), to the drive down "Route 1" (which separates East/Arab and West Jerusalem, and which, in part, was the armistice line between 1948-1967), to the stark differences in infrastructure and services between Arab and Jewish Areas. The more you learned, the more you knew how much life in this city was guided by the logic of occupation and discrimination (you can read more about the situation in Jerusalem here).
But somehow despite the odds, I made Jerusalem a home. I was a political activist, most significantly with Ta'ayush and along with like-minded friends, we tried to challenge this reality. But in 2003/4, with the expanding racist Wall, settlements and injustice, it felt like we were fighting a lost cause. I felt like I was being a part of the system of oppression, being an Israeli citizen, paying taxes that funded this system. And I felt like I needed better tools to fight. So I moved to the US for graduate school at NYU.
Since 2004, I have moved a lot: NYC->Jerusalem (1.5 years, research)->NYC->Oberlin, Ohio >NYC->Sewanee, TN->NYC->Houston, TX->Arcata, CA. Some of these were for a semester, some was for a year. But after so much moving, the question of where is home becomes hard to answer. The question of can you make a place home, even if for a while is even harder. The most clear answer is that home is where family is. I love my parents so much, and my mother makes our family home the most home place in the world!
But at the same time, my village has not been my place, at least since 1998, maybe even before.
And now, Jerusalem feels so alienating. I now, for the first time, I live in East Jerusalem. I live in Shu'afat, a Palestinian town that was annexed by Israel in 1967 to create the Jerusalem municipality as the "united Jerusalem" (the map of this Jerusalem, which never exited before, was created through annexing 28 Palestinian towns to west Jerusalem, with the logic of maximum territory, minimum population, see map and data. Most Palestinians in this area remain "permanent residents," not citizens. learn about the legal status here). Since then, the daily life and legal reality of the Palestinians in Shu'afat has been shaped by Israeli policies of limiting Palestinians life, and narrowing their expansion, and disconnecting them from the rest of the West Bank (needless to say, Gaza is even more out of reach).
This picture is near my place, and it says it all: the level of services that residents receive is far from what a "modern" city offers. Residents, who pay full municipal taxes, have to take the trash to these large containers, because there is no regular trash pickup. The infrastructure is neglected and underdeveloped. Although my village, and Palestinian towns inside Israel in general, receives much less services than the average Jewish towns, and tend to be overcrowded due to Israeli-imposed limited development and expansion possibilities, the reality here is far more severe.
So basically, the moment I step out, I see how occupation looks like. But the reality here is even more! I live near the light rail, so it's my main transportation mean (I will postpone the rant about the legal status for later, but for now, check this out!). Riding the train is quite an experience. You see guns everywhere! Yesterday, I got to see up close how a gun looks like.This picture is not zoomed, this gun actually hit my leg a couple of times. The train wasn't that crowded for her to stand so obliviously close to me. God, I wish some NYC-style subway role-enforcer could come teach people something!
And then there is religion, everywhere! I get to see how much religiosity has taken over. I know, Jerusalem has always been more conservative... there are many cynical about the argument of creeping religiosity etc., but it is quite startling to see all these heavily covered people, Muslims and Jews. Just see this:
Since 2004, I have moved a lot: NYC->Jerusalem (1.5 years, research)->NYC->Oberlin, Ohio >NYC->Sewanee, TN->NYC->Houston, TX->Arcata, CA. Some of these were for a semester, some was for a year. But after so much moving, the question of where is home becomes hard to answer. The question of can you make a place home, even if for a while is even harder. The most clear answer is that home is where family is. I love my parents so much, and my mother makes our family home the most home place in the world!
But at the same time, my village has not been my place, at least since 1998, maybe even before.
And now, Jerusalem feels so alienating. I now, for the first time, I live in East Jerusalem. I live in Shu'afat, a Palestinian town that was annexed by Israel in 1967 to create the Jerusalem municipality as the "united Jerusalem" (the map of this Jerusalem, which never exited before, was created through annexing 28 Palestinian towns to west Jerusalem, with the logic of maximum territory, minimum population, see map and data. Most Palestinians in this area remain "permanent residents," not citizens. learn about the legal status here). Since then, the daily life and legal reality of the Palestinians in Shu'afat has been shaped by Israeli policies of limiting Palestinians life, and narrowing their expansion, and disconnecting them from the rest of the West Bank (needless to say, Gaza is even more out of reach).
This picture is near my place, and it says it all: the level of services that residents receive is far from what a "modern" city offers. Residents, who pay full municipal taxes, have to take the trash to these large containers, because there is no regular trash pickup. The infrastructure is neglected and underdeveloped. Although my village, and Palestinian towns inside Israel in general, receives much less services than the average Jewish towns, and tend to be overcrowded due to Israeli-imposed limited development and expansion possibilities, the reality here is far more severe.
So basically, the moment I step out, I see how occupation looks like. But the reality here is even more! I live near the light rail, so it's my main transportation mean (I will postpone the rant about the legal status for later, but for now, check this out!). Riding the train is quite an experience. You see guns everywhere! Yesterday, I got to see up close how a gun looks like.This picture is not zoomed, this gun actually hit my leg a couple of times. The train wasn't that crowded for her to stand so obliviously close to me. God, I wish some NYC-style subway role-enforcer could come teach people something!
And then there is religion, everywhere! I get to see how much religiosity has taken over. I know, Jerusalem has always been more conservative... there are many cynical about the argument of creeping religiosity etc., but it is quite startling to see all these heavily covered people, Muslims and Jews. Just see this:
(In case you didn't get it, this burqa-clad woman is Jewish!)
Learn more about challenges to life if Jerusalem.
That is it for today!




Comments
Post a Comment