Jerusalem walks: On resilience
A friend gave me
a deadline for the chapter I’m writing, a pretty short one, and it works! So,
in the past couple of weeks, I’ve been mostly at my apartment, at my desk,
pushing through my work. I’ve been thinking a lot about history, what events
mean, how do you write to give people a sense of what this story is about, and
in ways, how to give a voice to historical actors, who have mostly been
forgotten. I’ve also given a lot of thought about what people’s choices in
their historical context teach us about the limits and possibilities of
political imagination in historical, and colonial transition, and what we can
learn from that.
But I also needed
to get out and breathe a bit, exercise, and think some more. I decided to go
walking (I’ve never been a big fan of gyms, the gym in my neighborhood is
gender-segregated with inconvenient hours for women, and oh so sadly, I don’t
have a bike!). Some of the days, I went walking in my old walking path, back
when I lived in French Hill.
It’s quite
strange how much this place has changed, and still how little. There is a new
gated-community sort of project, but mostly the built-up area is the same. The
people you encounter in the street, however, seem very different. Much more
religious, and much less local. I hear more English and French than Hebrew, and
there are also a lot more foreign workers (home and elderly care are now mostly
done by workers from Sri Lanka and the Philippines, and labor relations and the
dynamic with the local community in a Jewish –centric state is fascinating).
The
neighboring Palestinian village, Issawiyya, also kind of looks the same, but
things have become much worse since I left. Already while I was in college, the
State blocked one of the town’s main entrances, closest to the Hebrew University.
In partnership with the residents, we at Ta’ayush at the time tried very hard
to resist, we even went with shovels to break down the dirt mound that was
blocking the road. Since then, the roadblock has become a reality, with
concrete slaps blocking the way, and an army point just next to it. In 2003, we
tried so hard to make this place, literally right outside the university’s
gate, visible on campus, with limited success. Now, Issawiyya, with all Israeli
oppression, seems even more remote. Even though, from the windows of the shiny
new building for Advanced Studies in Humanities. It’s right there,
with all that is wrong with the occupation: over-crowdedness, because the town
can’t expand, among other things for the Hebrew University, house demolition
(because when people can’t build legally due to Israeli restrictions, they have
to live somewhere, so they build without permits. Here, here, and here is some more information on that), and severely neglected urban
space.
Another day, I
walked to East Jerusalem. I went to an event was held at the French Cultural
Center.
“Our products by Our hands”, which was organized by “Advancing the Rights of Vulnerable Palestinian Women and Children in East Jerusalem,” was a bazar empowering disempowered groups by selling products they make. The bazar
was small, only a few stalls, but the atmosphere was nice, the women were
amazing. They stood there, welcoming people, explaining about their products
and what they do, figuring out sales, and asking people to write them a note in
their visitors’ books. They came from different parts of East Jerusalem, from
communities that have by now been disempowered for generations. But they stood
there and smiled. They made an effort to support their families, and yes, they
practiced Sumoud, steadfastness, or resilience: the power to stay there, day in
and day out, at your home, facing more and more aggression and to say, or just
act: I’m Palestinian, and despite it all, I’m staying. I can only imagine how
hard it is, and I can only admire everyone who does stay and fight in their own
way for their rights to dignity and freedom in their own place and space.
The term
resilience has been on my mind recently. A colleague asked what people thought
about the term, and an interesting discussion developed on FB on this. I
learned that, in the US, for some it now raises negative connotations,
particularly in regarding People of Color. That is, the term is seen as a
way to tell certain groups that this is the situation, tough it out and deal
with it. I thought about that a lot, and maybe there is an unfair expectation
of certain groups to survive hard realities, but for me as a Palestinian, this
has always been a part of our national project. One that might have fully
internalized the power imbalance, but one that strongly decided that no matter
one, we stay in our land, and by our resilience, we undermine colonial designs
for us to disappear, physically and politically. That is what Yawm al-Ard was about, and that is what commemorating it every year says.
But walking back
from East Jerusalem to my apartment a few days ago, I got to think more about
what resilience really means.
From Salah el-Din Street, I walked by Israeli
expressions of sovereignty (Ministry of “Justice” and District court, later the
Israeli police headquarters, and the Border Police building, all spread around
the area to enforce Israeli control over occupied East Jerusalem). Then there are the
settlers, in their ever expanding presence in Sheikh Jarrah; the closed-down
Orient House; the streets that seem to be designed to make it harder to get
anywhere for Palestinians (when I was in college, there was the famous case,
among leftists at least, of the racist street lights, that worked not according
to traffic logic but accorded priority to settlers, now it’s much worst as the
infrastructure keeps getting redesigned for that). And then there is urban
neglect. I wrote some about it in my first post, but I can’t get over it. The
narrow streets (sometimes unpaved), crowded, unmaintained, and uncleaned. I
walk by big nice houses, some recently built, right next to this disaster of an urban space, and have to
wonder: what comes into account in making the decision to build a nice house, right there? Do you just do your best to better your own personal situation
because the communal and national seem to be ever worsening? Or can we see this
as also a sort of resilience/resistance, that no matter how bad it is, we live
the best we can until we can make it better? (I know I might be romanticizing
this now).
I also think about the meaning of public space in societies in
conflict: the city of Jerusalem and the Israeli state are neglecting the public
space in East Jerusalem, and they fail to provide basic services to people are
made pay taxes equivalent to West Jerusalem. But how about our own
responsibility? Do we not see it as our public space after all this time of
exclusion? I’ve also been thinking about it in my village, inside Israel "proper" (i.e. within 1949 armistice line). We’re not under occupation, but there are many layers of exclusion, and also
much neglect of the collective space. But there is also the local factors, as people throw their trash and discard
their old cars, and whatnot, in the bits of open spaces we have in the village.
If the Israeli state had a policy of disregard to our wellbeing, how do we take
responsibility for our own actions until we are recognized as a part of the
space and it is truly ours? (and here, the environment is a question I keep
thinking about: is it the strong impact of California, with its long heritage
of environmental advocacy and education that has made me think differently, or are
people here (Israelis and Palestinians) really behind in their environmental understanding or
concern?)



Comments
Post a Comment