On holidays and walls
This weekend was our holiday, 'Eid al-Adha ('eid: holiday, adha- sacrifice), in which Muslims celebrate that god replaced Ismail with a lamb to be sacrificed (those of us with less belief in them might feel less grateful, being that god told him to sacrifice his kid. And yes, it is the same story of the Binding of Isaac, just a different name). I spent the long weekend at home, 'celebrating' 'Eid with my family for the first time in years. And I discovered I didn't really miss anything. I love my family, and it is great spending time with them, but honestly, it's nicer on regular days.
My friend Elora posted this interesting article today.
It is about Egypt but the same goes to many places, I believe. For me, the biggest take away is the issue of doing things because you did them before (with, I agree with the article, the spin of exaggerated displays of religiosity). So, instead of having a nice family with our family, my father, like many others, had to go visit family members he hadn't seen since the last holiday, this distance being something all parties are content with. But twice a year, everyone performs the ritual of visiting extended family members as if that means anything. In fact, so many people are traveling abroad on the holiday just to avoid having to see each other! And in all that, I had to wonder, what's the point? That is, the only way I could accept this holiday (and most religious things) is that it's based on some moral sense, on the idea that for that day, on this occasion, we stop and think about the less fortunate, about the community we live in, and we sacrifice so that it is a better place, so that people in need are taken care of. But instead, sheep are killed, their meat distributed among family and friends (as someone said, it no longer has any aspect of distribution of wealth) and the millions of refugees continue being forgotten. I had half-jokingly stated that I'm not celebrating 'eid, in morning over Syria, Iraq, Yemen, Gaza, Rohingya, and many many more. But how many others truly thought about this? how many skipped the actual sacrifice of a lamb and sent money to one of the organizations trying to help? (UNHCR actually launched a campaign of Zakat, the religiously mandated almsgiving, for refugees. I wonder how many really did).
And from internal walls to external ones....
When I left Jerusalem in 2004, the wall was mostly a looming doom, and fighting against it was the major occupation in my life. At my job, I helped coordinate the efforts of various anti-occupation organizations on the topic, and wrote and gave tours explaining the legal and practical implications of the Wall. With Ta'ayush, I spent almost every weekend and most my evenings planning and executing activities against the Wall with communities in the Jerusalem area.
In July 2004, when the ICJ issued its decision against the Wall, there was a moment of hope, but only very passing, because Palestinians have become accustomed to international resolutions being useless when it comes to Palestine. Now, I see how much that was true. I haven't really seen the extent to which East Jerusalem was walled in the past few years (or maybe I tried hard not to see). But it seems now that you can't avoid the Wall (and yet, it also seems most Israeli can't see it).
Last week, I went on a walk in French Hill, 10 minutes from my current apartment in Shu'afat, and where I lived for most years during my years in Jerusalem (I walk there because, as a Jewish neighborhood, the infrastructure is so much better, with nice sidewalks and gardens, making an exercise much more pleasant).
This is what I could see for several minutes:
This neighborhood is Az-Zaim. Yes, that it is a walled off neighborhood. Here, it is a good time to stop on terminology. Usually, Palestine sympathizers insist on calling it the Wall, while Israel insists it is the "Security Barrier." It is true that this giant concrete structure (8 meters high, higher than the Berlin Wall) is not every where, and in many parts it is a system of fences (see specs here), but looking at this, can you call it anything but a Wall?
Most shocking was seeing the wall in Al-Ram.

It is hard to imagine, but this wall passed literally in the middle of the street, once bustling with life, now a surrounding this neighborhood. I spent so long there, first fighting the idea, then resisting the temporary wall (somewhere on the World Wide Web, there is a picture of Ta'ayush activists taking a hammer to the wall!).
Since these days, I haven't been there. Last week, traveling to Ramallah, my heart broke. In a way, I understand more the apathy in my neighborhood a few weeks ago when the demonstrations were raging in the Old City (see my blog on that). There is a force, in this case in a very profound physical manifestation, that pushes you to see the futility of resisting this well oiled oppressive machine, backed by American might, money, and diplomacy.
But in face of all that, people persist and adapt (waiting for change?) and at times, even have small victories, as in forcing Israel to back down from installing metal detectors.
But then again, the evacuation yesterday was a defeat of over a decade of resisting settler expansion in Shiekh Jarrah.
My friend Gadi, an amazing tireless activist, finds ways to find hope, even when it is hard to come by. That, I guess, is what keeps him going, active since the 1980s. Maybe that is what Palestinians in Jerusalem have, that allows them to hold on and persist. Maybe I need to work on that.


Comments
Post a Comment